• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Cusimano, Roberts & Mills, LLC

Alabama Personal Injury Lawyer - Gadsden Accident Attorney - Cusimano, Roberts & Mills, LLC

Header Right

Free Consultation
256-543-0400

  • Home
  • Our People
    • Gregory S. Cusimano
    • Michael L. Roberts
    • Emily Hawk Mills
    • Donald D. Knowlton
    • David Kimberley
    • Betsy Boggs Wells
  • Practice Areas
  • Our Successes
    • Results
    • Our Publications
    • Testimonials
    • Our Books
  • Recent News
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Call
Contact Us
News
  • Home
  • Our People
    • Gregory S. Cusimano
    • Michael L. Roberts
    • Emily Hawk Mills
    • Donald D. Knowlton
    • David Kimberley
    • Betsy Boggs Wells
  • Practice Areas
  • Our Successes
    • Results
    • Our Publications
    • Testimonials
    • Our Books
  • Recent News
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Arbitration – Another 5 to 4 decision U.S. Supremes

July 21, 2010

Scalia writes for what some have called the big business wing of the court, that if you signed an unfair arbitration agreement and therefore claim it is unenforceable, you still cannot go to court — the arbitrator gets to decide if it was unfair.

The main question involved is whether one is able to go to court to determine if an arbitration agreement could be set aside because it was legally unconscionable.

The Supreme Court said if the agreement says the arbitrator is to determine if the agreement is enforceable, then under the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”), the arbitrator will make that decision and you cannot go to court. Justice Scalia wrote for the 5 justices that prevailed saying if the challenge was just to a particular part of the agreement rather than the whole, then a court could decide. So if one claimed just part of the agreement was unenforceable a court could decide, but if you claimed the whole agreement was unenforceable the arbitrator got to decide? Interesting!

Justice John Paul Stevens, writing for what some have called the “people’s side of the court” dissented and criticized the majority for adopting a position not proposed by either party during briefing or oral arguments. From a legal standpoint it is nearly unheard of for the court to make a decision on an issue or facts not raised by either side. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen G. Breyer, and Sonia Sotomayor, joined in the dissent.

The lesson for all of us — don’t sign an arbitration agreement unless you are sure you know what you are doing. Understand that it will probably cost you more to go to arbitration than to court.

By Gregory S. Cusimano

Docket No.: 09-497
Petitioner: Rent-A-Center West, Inc.
Respondent: Antonio Jackson
Decided By: Roberts Court (2009-2010 )
Opinion: 561 U.S. ___ (2010)
Granted: Friday, January 15, 2010
Argued: Monday, April 26, 2010
Decided: Monday, June 21, 2010

Primary Sidebar

Contact Us

  • FREE CONSULTATION
    256-543-0400

Practice Areas

  • 18 – Wheeler Accidents
  • Auto Wrecks & Death Cases
  • Employment and Job Injuries
  • Wills & Estates
  • General Business & Business Litigation
  • Social Security & Disability Cases
  • Burn Injuries & Gas Explosions
  • Nursing Home Abuse & Injury
  • Divorce
  • Wrongful Death
  • Insurance Claims
  • Mesothelioma / Asbestos
  • Product Liability

Footer

HOME DISCLAIMER SITE MAP CONTACT US

153 S 9th St
Gadsden, AL 35901
Phone: 256-543-0400
Fax: 256-543-0488


We serve the following localities: Calhoun County including Anniston and Oxford; Etowah County including Boaz and Gadsden; Jefferson County including Bessemer, Birmingham, Hoover, and Vestavia Hills; Marshall County including Albertville and Guntersville; Talladega County including Sylacauga and Talladega; Cherokee County including Centre and Leesburg; and anywhere else in the country we feel we can be of assistance.

No representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Alabama Personal Injury Lawyer - Gadsden Accident Attorney - Cusimano, Roberts & Mills, LLC

Copyright © 2018, Cusimano, Roberts & Mills, LLC | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy