What Is a Contract Dispute?

A contract dispute happens when two or more parties disagree about an agreement or the duties it creates. Sometimes, one side claims that the other has failed to do what was promised. In other cases, both sides may disagree about what a particular term actually means or requires.

Contract disputes can involve questions such as:

• Is there a valid contract?
• What does the contract require each party to do?
• Did someone fail to make a required payment?
• Were goods or services delivered as promised?
• Was work completed correctly and on time?
• Did someone end the agreement improperly?
• Did one side’s actions cause the other financial harm?

Not every disagreement amounts to a legal issue. The wording of the agreement, the actions of the parties, and the facts surrounding the situation all matter.

At Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton, our Gadsden contract dispute lawyers look closely at those details. Before telling you how to fight a contract dispute, we work to understand exactly what happened and what needs to be done to help you recover.

Types of Contract Disputes Our Attorneys Handle

Contract disputes can occur in businesses large and small. They can involve a single transaction or a long-standing business relationship.

Our contract dispute attorneys have extensive experience handling business and commercial disputes involving contracts and agreements. These can include:

• Business and commercial contracts
• Sales and purchase agreements
• Sales and services contracts
• Partnership and business agreements
• Bank and loan transactions
• Secured transactions
• Vendor and supplier agreements
• Construction contracts
• Real estate agreements
• Non-compete and non-solicitation agreements

Sometimes, a contract dispute is over money. Sometimes it’s about whether work was performed correctly. Other cases involve ownership, deadlines, or whether someone can walk away from an agreement.

No matter if the disagreement is a result of breach of contract, unclear terms, validity, or anything else, our Gadsden contract dispute attorneys will focus on what the contract says, what actually happened, and the best way to ensure you are treated fairly.

A Closer Look at Breach of Contract

To prove a breach of contract in Alabama, four basic elements need to be established:

1. There is an agreement
2. You did what you were supposed to do
3. The other party did not do what they were supposed to do
4. You suffered losses because of it

To establish this, your breach of contract attorney may need to gather evidence including:

• The contract itself
• Any amendments to the contract
• Emails and messages
• Invoices and receipts
• Payment records
• Purchase orders
• Change orders
• Business records
• Photographs
• Records showing work performed

Details matter in a breach of contract claim. A single email, invoice, or provision can change how a dispute is resolved.

The contract breach lawyers at Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton will carefully review the agreement and the history behind it. We’re thorough in our investigations so we can know all of the facts before proceeding.

Stories From Our Gadsden Community

Real Clients. True Stories. Successful Fights.

“Emily is a rottweiler attorney with such a nice approach. She’s so sweet and everyone is so drawn to that. Before you know it, the defense attorney and their client are being hit with a deer in the headlight kinda look after she’s done in the courtroom!!!! I will hire her over and over and over again. I’ve seen her in action on my behalf for 2 different cases now and she is absolutely incredible!!!“

–Charity Haney

View All

Does a Contract Have to Be in Writing in Alabama?

No. Not every contract has to be in writing in Alabama to be enforceable. However, Alabama law does require certain types of agreements to be written down.

Alabama’s Statute of Frauds applies to several categories of contracts. For example, certain agreements that can’t be performed within one year generally need to be in writing. Alabama law also generally requires contracts involving the sale of land or an interest in land to be in writing, subject to limited exceptions.

That doesn’t mean an oral agreement can’t be enforced. Whether an agreement is valid can depend on:

• What the parties promised
• How long the agreement was supposed to last
• What type of transaction was involved
• Whether any parties to the contract have already met their end of the agreement
• What evidence exists to show an agreement was made

If you are unsure whether an oral or informal agreement can be enforced, bring what you have to the Gadsden contract dispute lawyers at Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton. Emails, texts, invoices, and the other party’s conduct may all work to help build a clear understanding of what happened.

What Remedies Are Available in an Alabama Contract Dispute?

The right remedy depends on the contract, the cause of the dispute, and what it has cost you. In many cases, the goal of contract damages is to place the party that suffered losses as close as possible to the position they would have been in if the agreement had been honored.

Depending on the circumstances, this can involve:

• Money owed under the agreement
• Financial losses caused by the breach
• Other damages allowed under the contract or Alabama law
• Enforcement of certain contractual obligations
• Specific performance, in appropriate cases

Specific performance means asking a court to require someone to perform an obligation rather than simply pay money. It’s not available in every case, but may be a remedy in some.

The best result isn’t always the biggest lawsuit. Sometimes, all you need is a payment or an agreement enforced. Sometimes, you need a dispute resolved quickly so you can get back to business. At Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton, our contract dispute attorneys keep your actual goal in mind and work to secure the settlement or verdict that you deserve.

Does a Contract Dispute Have to Go to Court?

No. Many contract disputes can be resolved without a trial.

Depending on the agreement and the positions of the parties, options may include:

• Direct negotiations
• Negotiations between attorneys
• Mediation
• Arbitration
• Filing a lawsuit
• Taking the case to trial

The contract itself may also include terms that determine how disputes are handled.

A good contract dispute lawyer will know when to negotiate and when to fight. Filing a lawsuit just to make noise rarely helps anyone. But neither does backing down when the other side refuses to honor a valid agreement.

The Gadsden contract dispute lawyers at Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton work to find the most practical solution. When a fair resolution is possible, we pursue it. When litigation is necessary, our trial attorneys are more than prepared to handle it.

How Long Do I Have to File a Disputed Contract Claim in Alabama?

The statute of limitations for filing a contract dispute claim in Alabama depends on the type of contract and claim involved. Alabama provides a six-year deadline for several types of contract-related actions, including actions based on written promises that are not under seal.

Different rules can apply to certain contracts, however. For example, Alabama’s Uniform Commercial Code generally provides a four-year deadline for a breach of contract for the sale of goods.

Determining the correct deadline may require more than looking at the date someone stopped meeting their end of a contract. Because deadlines can vary, it’s always a good idea to discuss your claim with a contract dispute attorney as soon as possible.

At Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton, our team moves quickly to help avoid deadline issues. We have the resources, background, and experience necessary to work within these various statutes of limitation and keep solid claims moving forward.

Why Choose Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton for a Contract Dispute?

Contracts are about details. So is our firm.

Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton is a small but mighty law firm with nearly 200 years of combined experience. We believe clients deserve careful preparation and clear answers, not unnecessary legal jargon.

When you work with our Gadsden contract dispute attorneys, you can expect:

• Deep experience. We have been handling complex business and commercial litigation cases for decades.
• Thorough investigation. We study the contract, the documents, and the history behind the agreement.
• Straight answers. We explain your options, risks, and possible next steps in plain English.
• Practical strategy. We focus on what you actually need to accomplish.
• Trial readiness. If a fair solution can’t be reached, we’re prepared to take the dispute to court.

Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton has been part of the Gadsden community for years, but our reputation and experience extend throughout Alabama. Our attorneys frequently lecture, write, and publish works on Alabama Tort Law, and are frequently contacted by other firms for advice and co-counsel. If you’re facing a dispute over a contract or agreement, we can help you understand your rights and explore what options might be available.

Talk to a Contract Dispute Lawyer in Gadsden

Contract problems usually don’t disappear on their own. Cusimano, Roberts, Mills & Knowlton can help you reach the best resolution. Use our online contact form or call us today to schedule a confidential case review and learn more. We help clients resolve disputes throughout Etowah County and across Alabama.